Skip to main content

P1 Week One


Joanna Weiss
"Battling children’s obesity"
Are avocados good for you? What about plain cereal? Parental food myths are part of a larger problem in our culture
The Boston Globe
September 6, 2011

In Joanna Weiss’s “Battling children’s obesity,” she describes how children’s obesity is becoming an epidemic of sorts. Children’s obesity has one primary cause: the lack of nutritional education. Parents have the wrong ideas about what or what not to feed their children. She discusses the stigma of nutrition that the supermarkets and food industry display and how incorrect they are. Throughout the article, she quotes Dr. David Ludwig, who works at the child-obesity clinic at Children’s Hospital. Weiss follows the story of 10-year-old Ezra Fellman-Balu’s visit to Dr. Ludwig. In Ezra’s case, he was exercising regularly and eating what the majority of people think are healthy foods. However, Dr. Ludwig helped establish what foods Ezra should stick to and which foods he should shy away from eating. For example, Ezra typically ate pasta for dinner, so, Dr. Ludwig stated that pasta was a processed carbohydrate which “will make Ezra hungrier in the short term and heavier in the long term.” Joanna Weiss writes with a formal tone using specific claims and evidence to back these claims. She uses quotes and statistics from people of authority such as Dr. David Ludwig and Phil Edmundson, a Boston insurance company chief, to establish ethos. Weiss also incorporates short anecdotes of Ezra’s time while visiting Dr. Ludwig. She uses a contradictory, ironic idea at the beginning of the article, as she states that Dr. Ludwig offered Ezra a piece of chocolate during their appointment. She later describes that this was dark chocolate and was considered a health food. To conclude her article, she poses the question, “If someone came up to you on a street corner and told you that chocolate could help you lose weight, would you believe him?” This question ties the reader back to the beginning of the article while also picking the reader’s brain about the assumptions of fighting childhood obesity. 

Comments

  1. Comment for the author: Since this article was published in 2011, has advocating for a bill that would eliminate the sales tax exemption on sugar-sweetened beverages created any changes? Have the statistics of child obesity lessened or become greater?

    ReplyDelete
  2. The article covers one of the major issues America is facing today. Weiss gains ethos within her article by describing the story of Ezra and how he and his family have tried to eat healthier. Ezra's unhealthy body is just one of the millions of obese people who face deadly diseases due to food companies and their false advertising when it comes to "safe" foods and "unhealthy" foods.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Child obesity is a prevalent problem and also a topic I see both social media and writers address. It has affected the whole world, but especially the United States. It is interesting to see how ignorant and naive people can be when it comes to believing certain foods are healthy or unhealthy. The purpose of this article is to inform those of the dangers of over eating, advise others to eat healthier, and expose and reform how advertising can influence one's eating habits.

    ReplyDelete
  4. The author's use of the example from a real physician helps support his claim. With the support of a practicing physician, the author appeals to ethos. Even though the author may not be very qualified to discuss the topic, her claims are corroborated by a medical professional. This is enough to convince readers of what she is saying.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

P3 Week Three

Patt Morrison “Column: GOP strategist Rick WIlson on Trump’s loud, messy, ugly’ 2020 campaign”   The Los Angeles Times December 6 2019 In Patt Morrison’s article, “GOP strategist Rick Wilson on Trump’s loud, messy, ugly’ 2020 campaign”, Morrison interviews Rick Wilson to gain insight into his views of Trump and the belief that our democracy is declining due to Trump’s actions. Wilson explains that Trump is neither a conservative or liberal. He is an authoritarian, precisely one who destroys the securities that protect Americans from the behavior Trump exhibits. Wilson gives an interesting viewpoint as he is a Republican. However, he completely disagrees with most of Trump’s actions, which prove that Trump does not follow the common ideological beliefs of a sound Republican. Morrison questions Wilson about what makes Republicans support Trump, although they disagree with his actions. I find Wilson’s response to be almost humorous as he explains that they are scared of him,...

P1 Week Three

Joanna Weiss "About-face on the perp walk" But public opinion renders judgment, even when legal system cannot The Boston Globe August 27, 2011 http://archive.boston.com/bostonglobe/editorial_opinion/oped/articles/2011/08/27/about_face_on_the_perp_walk/ In “About-face on the perp walk,” written by Joanna Weiss, she addresses a highly controversial topic– the accusations of rape against Dominique Strauss-Kahn. He was arrested in May of 2010 for sexual assault, and since then, prosecutors dropped the charges because the apparent victim had lied previously about similar accusations. Weiss states that her initial reaction to the case was wrong. However, she leaves the reader with the feeling that the situation is unfinished and that we will never know the real story. Weiss writes with an informal tone as she begins the article with this statement: “SO I was wrong about the perp walk.” She writes very personally, and it sounds as though she is having a conversation w...

P2 Week Four

Michelle Goldberg “On Ukraine, Trump is a Con Man, but He’s Also a Mark” Corrupt forces find it easy to manipulate this president. The New York Times November 4, 2019 In one of Goldberg's recent articles, "On Ukraine, Trump is a Con Man, but He's Also a Mark," Goldberg discusses the current Ukranian relations with President Trump and addresses the confusion associated with the news. Unlike Goldberg's usual articles, she does not bash or undermine Trump. Instead, she takes a more sophisticated, factual approach. She maintains a formal tone through the piece, which causes her audience to respect her opinions after hearing all of the information. Goldberg establishes credibility by quoting Kenneth McCallion, a New York lawyer who once represented the Prime Minister of Ukraine. Therefore, he is a credible source due to how close he was to the Ukranian government and the knowledge he took from that experience. She also quotes Buzzfeed News, CNN, and the Just...