Skip to main content

P2 Week Two

Michelle Goldberg
With impeachment looming, it’s time to take to the streets again.
The New York Times
October 21, 2019

Michelle Goldberg’s most recent article, “1, 2, 3, 4, Trump Can’t Rule Us Anymore,” investigates the history of mass protest and answers the question as to why Americans seem to have fallen dormant to protesting Trump. To begin the article, Goldberg discusses current major demonstrations in other countries such as Hong Kong, Lebanon, and Chile. She then poses the question that even though the rate of mass protests has increased, why isn’t the same change occurring in America against President Trump? She answers this question by making two arguments. The first being that Americans are tired of protesting and seeing no results. She explains that Americans are used to Trump’s immoral acts and unlawful decisions, and believe their protests will not make a change.

In contrast, her second argument is that people are focusing their power to protest into organizing other presidential candidates such as Elizabeth Warren. Goldberg establishes credibility by quoting Erica Chenoweth, a Harvard professor, and author, and Dana Fisher, a professor at the University of Maryland and author of “American Resistance: From the Women’s March to the Blue Wave.” To finish the piece, Goldberg provides her advice to Americans. She urges them to create a public protest surrounding Trump’s impeachment. She even includes a plan that Leah Greenberg, a co-founder of the anti-Trump organization, Indivisible, set in place. Goldberg states, “Once the House votes to send articles of impeachment to the Senate, there needs to be a public groundswell to force the Senate majority leader, Mitch McConnell, to allow a thorough and transparent trial. Then, assuming the evidence is as compelling as it seems, there should be mass nonviolent action calling for Trump’s removal.” Throughout Goldberg’s article, the purpose is unclear and seems to be informative. However, by Goldberg providing her opinion on the matter, her goal is to persuade the reader to take action against President Trump. She inspires her audience to demand the impeachment of Trump through mass nonviolent protest.

Comments

  1. Comment for the author:
    Compared to last week's article, this article is much more investigative and analyzes American's feelings toward protest. Your arguments are backed by studies and quotes from people of authority, which makes them credible. Your article left me with one question, if Americans have shown less interest in protesting recently, how do you think the turn out will be at the protest surrounding Trump's impeachment? Do you expect Americans will still be unmotivated?

    ReplyDelete
  2. While reading the article, I loved the author's tone and diction because it help to evoke emotions and use appeals to its advantage. I also like the content, foreign affairs has been at the top of every pundit I've read and it is nice to see differentiating opinions from the various columnists.

    ReplyDelete
  3. When Goldberg was my pundit, I always noticed how she would used a lot of ethos to establish her credibility. And, like this article, she does again. Also, I like how she explores the more emotional side to the protest topic, not just facts and statistics.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I was uninformed on the decrease in mass protest over Trump in America. It seems to make sense because despite all the protests surrounding him that have occurred in the past, Trump still remains in office. Goldberg's kept a confused and concerned tone throughout her article. I think her purpose is to find and expose the reason why protests have decreased to maybe argue against and promote more protest.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

P3 Week Three

Patt Morrison “Column: GOP strategist Rick WIlson on Trump’s loud, messy, ugly’ 2020 campaign”   The Los Angeles Times December 6 2019 In Patt Morrison’s article, “GOP strategist Rick Wilson on Trump’s loud, messy, ugly’ 2020 campaign”, Morrison interviews Rick Wilson to gain insight into his views of Trump and the belief that our democracy is declining due to Trump’s actions. Wilson explains that Trump is neither a conservative or liberal. He is an authoritarian, precisely one who destroys the securities that protect Americans from the behavior Trump exhibits. Wilson gives an interesting viewpoint as he is a Republican. However, he completely disagrees with most of Trump’s actions, which prove that Trump does not follow the common ideological beliefs of a sound Republican. Morrison questions Wilson about what makes Republicans support Trump, although they disagree with his actions. I find Wilson’s response to be almost humorous as he explains that they are scared of him,...

P1 Week Three

Joanna Weiss "About-face on the perp walk" But public opinion renders judgment, even when legal system cannot The Boston Globe August 27, 2011 http://archive.boston.com/bostonglobe/editorial_opinion/oped/articles/2011/08/27/about_face_on_the_perp_walk/ In “About-face on the perp walk,” written by Joanna Weiss, she addresses a highly controversial topic– the accusations of rape against Dominique Strauss-Kahn. He was arrested in May of 2010 for sexual assault, and since then, prosecutors dropped the charges because the apparent victim had lied previously about similar accusations. Weiss states that her initial reaction to the case was wrong. However, she leaves the reader with the feeling that the situation is unfinished and that we will never know the real story. Weiss writes with an informal tone as she begins the article with this statement: “SO I was wrong about the perp walk.” She writes very personally, and it sounds as though she is having a conversation w...

P2 Week Four

Michelle Goldberg “On Ukraine, Trump is a Con Man, but He’s Also a Mark” Corrupt forces find it easy to manipulate this president. The New York Times November 4, 2019 In one of Goldberg's recent articles, "On Ukraine, Trump is a Con Man, but He's Also a Mark," Goldberg discusses the current Ukranian relations with President Trump and addresses the confusion associated with the news. Unlike Goldberg's usual articles, she does not bash or undermine Trump. Instead, she takes a more sophisticated, factual approach. She maintains a formal tone through the piece, which causes her audience to respect her opinions after hearing all of the information. Goldberg establishes credibility by quoting Kenneth McCallion, a New York lawyer who once represented the Prime Minister of Ukraine. Therefore, he is a credible source due to how close he was to the Ukranian government and the knowledge he took from that experience. She also quotes Buzzfeed News, CNN, and the Just...